"Justin Hughes" (justinhughes54)
03/30/2016 at 09:05 • Filed to: three wheels good
3
10|
"Justin Hughes" (justinhughes54)
03/30/2016 at 09:05 • Filed to: three wheels good | 3
| 10 |
While checking out !!!error: Indecipherable SUB-paragraph formatting!!! at !!!error: Indecipherable SUB-paragraph formatting!!! , they asked me if I’d heard of !!!error: Indecipherable SUB-paragraph formatting!!! . I had not. Later on I stumbled across their display, and was intrigued by what I saw. I understood why Elio had asked me about them - Arcimoto, like Elio, was showing a three-wheeled economy vehicle with tandem seating for two. But they actually turned out to be very different vehicles once I looked under the skin.
Read on Right Foot Down or continue below
That skin, itself, is one of the most notable differences. While the Elio has an enclosed cockpit, the base model of the Arcimoto SRK is open. A roll cage surrounds you, as well as a windshield and a roof, but the sides are more open than a Jeep Wrangler with the doors removed. Body panels are available as an option, but don’t expect anything fancy, with the exception of the “Eagle Wing” door that opens up and over the roof like a simplified Tesla Model X. Each of the tandem seats has not one, but two three-point seat belts. Fastening both essentially straps you into a four point harness. Heated seats and controls are standard equipment, useful for those chilly mornings.
Another major difference is the controls. Both vehicles are legally considered motorcycles, since they have less than four wheels. But while the Elio drives like a car, Arcimoto uses motorcycle controls. The setup was quite familiar to me as a motorcyclist myself, but it employs an entirely different skill set than a traditional car, or the Elio. As a result, the SRK will not qualify for the “autocycle” category that Elio is pushing to allow people to drive their cars without a motorcycle license.
!!! UNKNOWN CONTENT TYPE !!!
Arcimoto doesn’t seem to be concerned about this, though. They point out that you’re allowed to take your motorcycle license road test on whatever bike you bring, and therefore you’d be allowed to take it on an SRK. This would be the one, and only, instance in which I would NOT recommend taking the MSF Basic RiderCourse to get a motorcycle license, because almost nothing you’d learn about riding a two-wheeler would apply to the Arcimoto. You could also ride this on just a motorcycle learner’s permit as long as you follow its restrictions, which vary by state. While a learner’s permit for a car requires a passenger, a permit for a motorcycle typically prohibits one, so you could certainly teach yourself to ride it without much difficulty.
But the biggest difference between the Elio and the Arcimoto is the powertrain. The SRK utilizes two small but strong electric motors, each powering one of the front wheels. You sit on top of the battery, which stretches the length of the vehicle. Like a motorcycle there are two brake controls, but the foot pedal operates the mechanical brakes on all three wheels while the handlebar brake lever controls regenerative braking, which recharges the batteries. Arcimoto claims a range of 70 miles (130 with an extended range package), 0-60 in 7.5 seconds, and a top speed of 80mph. Given the SRK’s weight of a tick over 1,000lbs and the instant-on power delivery of electric motors, I believe these figures. And this is only 60% of the motors’ full potential. Arcimoto turned the power down to keep the SRK from burning up its tires like a front wheel drive Challenger Hellcat. I wonder how long it would be until the aftermarket develops a Tesla-like “insane mode” to unleash the SRK’s full potential, voiding every warranty and all regard for safety in the process.
!!!error: Indecipherable SUB-paragraph formatting!!!
So really, despite using the same general formula, the Elio and Arcimoto SRK are very different vehicles. In fact, the two companies don’t even consider each other to be competitors. While Elio has built a very small three-wheeled car, Arcimoto has created a Tuk-Tuk for the 21st century. I think this is wonderful, because Tuk-Tuks are awesome, as demonstrated by this video of the greatest Tuk-Tuk chase ever.
Seriously, though, I think the Arcimoto SRK has the potential to be the electric vehicle for the masses. A Tesla it is not, but with a target price of $11,900 before incentives, it’s nearly a third the price of a Nissan Leaf, and a full Leaf less expensive than the eagerly anticipated “poor man’s” Tesla Model 3. I could see the SRK being particularly popular in cities, whose dense traffic gives the electric drivetrain a major advantage in overall efficiency. There’s even a fleet version, the Deliverator, that replaces the back seat with a good sized cargo area, making the SRK a great choice for city deliveries ranging from pizza to legal documents to human blood. Yet it also has the speed and performance to keep up with traffic outside of the city.
There is one more big difference between the Elio and the Arcimoto SRK. I’ve personally seen the SRK in action. While Elio is not yet allowing test drives of their prototype, I watched the SRK maneuver slowly through a roped off area of the Javits Center. While I absolutely believe that the Elio is fully capable of self propulsion as well, seeing is believing, and personally I think seeing the more radical SRK in action was even more impressive than seeing the more traditional Elio go for a drive. (That’s probably the first time the Elio has ever been called “traditional,” but with a gas motor and manual transmission, it is in this case.)
Arcimoto calls their three wheeled car bike thing “The Everyday Electric.” Though I’d need the extended range package for my daily commute, I could see myself taking this to work regularly. Despite being close to twice the price of an Elio, over time it would make up that difference in savings on gas. State and federal electric vehicle tax credits could also go a long way toward paying the premium over an Elio. I look forward to seeing what the future holds for both of these futuristic vehicles.
(Photo credits: Arcimoto, Justin Hughes)
Follow @justinhughes54 on Twitter
not for canada - australian in disguise
> Justin Hughes
03/29/2016 at 19:43 |
|
I absolutely adore the Arcimoto and the whole concept behind it. The main problem is that people compare it too much to a car, you shouldn’t be comparing it to a car. You should be comparing it to a motorcycle. Suddenly it all makes much more sense.
1111111111111111111111
> Justin Hughes
03/29/2016 at 19:50 |
|
I was neighbours with one of there developers a couple years ago. It’s a great looking prototype. Go Eugene.
|
Justin Hughes
> not for canada - australian in disguise
03/29/2016 at 19:51 |
|
I agree. It’s kind of the electric Elio of motorcycles. But I did write this for a car site, so I tried to keep it at least a little bit related to cars. :) But then again, Arcimoto themselves were showing it at the New York International AUTO Show, so it’s a connection they, themselves, are making.
pip bip - choose Corrour
> Justin Hughes
03/30/2016 at 03:26 |
|
10/10 would hoon.
McMike
> Justin Hughes
03/30/2016 at 09:21 |
|
http://oppositelock.kinja.com/arcimoto-the-1…
I added the “one trike leave” to make a Thunderdome joke. Honestly, I think they’ll both fail.
|
Justin Hughes
> McMike
03/30/2016 at 10:00 |
|
I hope both succeed, but they certainly have some challenges ahead of them. The markets for each vehicle may not be as big as they think they are, and there’s the matter of continuing to find funding until they come to market. Both are planning on that for next year, so we’ll see. Plus there’s the distribution and maintenance network to think about.
|
McMike
> Justin Hughes
03/30/2016 at 10:15 |
|
I’m not hoping they fail, I just don’t think that 1) Elio will ever deliver a car for under $12K, and 2) Anyone would buy a three-wheeled open electric golf cart for $12K. Maybe an enclosed three-wheeled cart, but not open like that.
|
Justin Hughes
> McMike
03/30/2016 at 10:33 |
|
They will have an enclosed version.
I agree the idea may be too radical for large scale sales, and possibly not enough to keep the company in business. The same goes for Elio, though with over 50k reservations I have a bit more faith in their viability - if they can keep the price down to $6,800 as promised.
|
McMike
> Justin Hughes
03/30/2016 at 10:36 |
|
Yeah, I saw that enclosed version.
I wish them the best of luck. Both of them.
|
Justin Hughes
> McMike
03/30/2016 at 10:38 |
|
